Diminished Value
Glossary

What Is Vehicle History Report?

Records like Carfax or AutoCheck that show accident history and reduce buyer willingness to pay full market price.

Definition

A vehicle history report aggregates data from insurers, police, DMVs, and auctions to show whether a vehicle has been in an accident, had title issues, or sustained damage. Services like Carfax and AutoCheck are widely used by dealers and private buyers when pricing used cars.

Why it matters for your claim

Accident history on a report creates stigma that persists after repairs. This stigma is the core reason diminished value exists — buyers pay less even when the car looks and drives fine.

  • Accident flags on history reports typically persist for the life of the vehicle.
  • Repair quality does not remove the accident entry from most reports.
  • Market comparables without accident history illustrate the price gap.
  • Insurers may argue stigma is speculative — comps disprove this.

Common questions

Does a Carfax accident always reduce value?

Nearly always in practice. Buyers and dealers routinely discount vehicles with reported accidents compared to clean-history comps in the same market.

Get your free diminished value estimate

Free market-backed estimate in 60 seconds — backed by comparable sales, not a generic calculator.

Free · 60 seconds

Before you settle

Insurance already picked a number. Get a second opinion.

Repaired or totaled — we compare your car against real market data and show you what was left out of the offer.

Free · 60 seconds · All 50 states