Skip to content
Featured guide

How to Claim Diminished Value From the At-Fault Driver's Insurer

If someone else caused the crash, the loss in your car's value is part of the damage they caused. Here is why that claim is often stronger than one under your own policy, and how to make it.

Why This Claim Is Different From One on Your Own Policy

A claim under your own collision coverage, a first-party claim, is limited by your policy's wording. Courts in Texas and Florida have read the common promise to repair or replace with property of like kind and quality as not covering a fully repaired car's loss of value. [1] [2]

A claim against the at-fault driver, a third-party claim, is different. The Texas Supreme Court drew that line itself: it said a measure of damages designed to make an injured third party whole may apply when the insurer's duty comes from liability coverage, but not to a policyholder's own collision coverage. [1]

Georgia went the other way on the first-party side: its Supreme Court held that State Farm's policies there did cover loss of value. [3] See Georgia Diminished Value Claims.

What You Need to Make the Claim

  • Evidence the other driver was at fault: a police report, photos, witness details, or the insurer's acceptance of liability.
  • The repair estimate and final invoice, showing what was repaired or replaced and whether the frame or structure was involved.
  • The car's value just before the accident, its pre-loss value, supported by comparable vehicles.
  • Evidence of its value after repair. An Arizona appeals court held that an owner does not have to sell the car to prove the loss, and that an expert appraisal of the values before and after can establish it. [4]

How to File, Step by Step

  1. 1.Open a property damage claim with the at-fault driver's insurer and get a claim number. You do not pay a deductible on a claim against another driver's insurer. [5]
  2. 2.Get the car repaired and keep every document.
  3. 3.Put a number on the loss in value. See How to Calculate Diminished Value.
  4. 4.Send a written demand with your evidence. See How to Write a Diminished Value Demand Letter.
  5. 5.Negotiate in writing. See How to Negotiate a Diminished Value Claim.

Read anything you are asked to sign. The California Department of Insurance warns against signing a release for the other party in exchange for payment of your deductible. [6] A release can end other claims from the same accident, so check that it does not cover diminished value before you sign.

If the Insurer Refuses or Stalls

  • Ask for the refusal and its reasons in writing.
  • You can file the repair claim under your own collision coverage instead and pay your deductible; your insurer will then usually try to recover from the other company. [5] Your own policy may not pay diminished value, though.
  • In North Carolina, liability policies must include an appraisal process for diminished value disputes above a set threshold. [7] See How the Appraisal Clause Works.
  • Contact your state insurance department, or consider a lawyer or small claims court before the deadline runs out.

Fault rules matter too. North Carolina's insurance department notes that the state's contributory negligence law bars a driver from collecting damages if found partly at fault. [8]

Deadlines in Five States

If the claim does not settle, the deadline that matters is the statute of limitations for a lawsuit over damage to property. These are the general periods as of November 2026:

General time limits for property damage lawsuits
StatePeriodStatute
California3 yearsCode of Civil Procedure § 338(c)(1)
Texas2 yearsCivil Practice and Remedies Code § 16.003(a)
Florida2 years for negligenceFlorida Statutes § 95.11(5)(a)
North Carolina3 yearsGeneral Statutes § 1-52(4)
Arizona2 yearsRevised Statutes § 12-542(3)

Sources: California [9], Texas [10], Florida [11], North Carolina [12], Arizona [13]. Florida's period for negligence was four years before a 2023 change [14], so for an accident from around then, ask a Florida attorney which period applies. Each state has exceptions to these periods. If you are close to a deadline, talk to a lawyer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I claim diminished value from the other driver's insurance?

Usually, yes, if the other driver was at fault. The claim is measured by your state's law on damage caused by others, not by your own policy's wording.

Do I pay a deductible on a claim against the other driver?

No. The Texas Department of Insurance notes that you do not pay a deductible when you claim against another driver's insurer.

Do I have to sell my car to prove diminished value?

Not in Arizona, where an appeals court held that an expert appraisal of the car's value before and after can prove the loss. Rules in other states may differ.

How long do I have to file a diminished value claim?

The deadline that matters most is your state's statute of limitations for property damage lawsuits: two years in Texas, Florida and Arizona and three in California and North Carolina, as of November 2026, with exceptions.

What if I was partly at fault?

It depends on the state. In North Carolina, contributory negligence can bar recovery if you were partly at fault. Other states have different rules, so check yours.

Should I sign a release to get my deductible paid?

Read it first. The California Department of Insurance warns against signing a release for the other party in exchange for your deductible, because it may end your other claims.

About This Content

Published by Value Pilot
Last updated: November 10, 2026

Value Pilot publishes educational information to help vehicle owners understand vehicle valuation and insurance claim documentation. Content is based on publicly available regulatory, legal, and industry sources and is reviewed periodically for accuracy. Insurance requirements vary by state, policy, claim type, and circumstances. Value Pilot does not provide legal advice, and estimates or analyses do not guarantee a particular insurance settlement or claim outcome.

Sources & References

  1. [1] American Manufacturers Mutual Insurance Co. v. Schaefer, No. 02-0295 (Tex. Oct. 24, 2003)
  2. [2] Siegle v. Progressive Consumers Insurance Co., No. SC01-1219 (Fla. May 23, 2002)
  3. [3] State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co. v. Mabry, 274 Ga. 498 (2001)
  4. [4] Oliver v. Henry, No. 1 CA-CV 10-0701 (Ariz. Ct. App. 2011)
  5. [5] Texas Department of Insurance — Auto Insurance Guide
  6. [6] California Department of Insurance — So You've Had an Accident, What's Next?
  7. [7] North Carolina General Statutes § 20-279.21 — Motor Vehicle Liability Policy
  8. [8] North Carolina Department of Insurance — After an Accident
  9. [9] California Code of Civil Procedure § 338 — Three Years
  10. [10] Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 16.003 — Two-Year Limitations Period
  11. [11] Florida Statutes § 95.11 (2025) — Limitations Other Than for the Recovery of Real Property
  12. [12] North Carolina General Statutes § 1-52 — Three Years
  13. [13] Arizona Revised Statutes § 12-542 — Two-Year Limitation
  14. [14] Florida Statutes § 95.11 (2006)

Related reading

See what your car lost.

Free · About 60 seconds · No email needed