Skip to content
Featured guide

Texas Diminished Value and Total Loss Rules

Texas courts have closed one route to diminished value and left another open. Here is which is which, plus how total loss disputes and claim deadlines work, as of November 2026.

If Your Car Was Repaired: Diminished Value

In American Manufacturers Mutual v. Schaefer, the Texas Supreme Court held that the Texas Standard Personal Auto Policy does not obligate an insurer to pay a policyholder for a car's diminished market value when it has been adequately repaired. The court relied on the policy's promise to repair or replace with property of like kind and quality. [1] A Texas appeals court reached the same result for a fully and adequately repaired car, while noting that diminished value claims can also come from improper or inferior repairs. [2]

The court also explained why a claim against the at-fault driver is different: a tort measure of damages, designed to make an injured third party whole, may apply when the insurer's duty comes from liability coverage. [1] So in Texas, diminished value is usually claimed from the other driver's insurer. See How to Claim Diminished Value From the At-Fault Driver's Insurer.

On a claim against another driver's insurer, you pay no deductible. If that insurer refuses to pay and you have collision coverage, you can claim from your own insurer instead and pay your deductible; your insurer will then usually pursue the other company. [3]

If Your Car Was Totaled

The Texas Department of Insurance gives no fixed percentage for when a car is totaled. It says a car is likely to be totaled when repairs cost about as much as its value or more, and that some insurers may total a car even when repairs would cost less. [4] The settlement is the car's actual cash value, which the department describes as the cost to replace the car minus depreciation. [3]

If you think the offer is too low, the department suggests: [5]

  • Find what cars of the same make, model and year sell for near you, with written quotes from used car dealers and local listings.
  • Write down upgrades and features that add value.
  • Ask the adjuster to pay more, using that evidence.
  • If the insurer will not move, ask about the appraisal process in your policy.
  • Check your purchase papers for gap coverage if you owe more than the car is worth.

If you keep the car, the insurer subtracts its salvage value. A repaired salvage car needs a new title from the Texas Department of Motor Vehicles before it can be driven, [4] and a car with a nonrepairable title cannot be retitled or registered. [3]

The Appraisal Clause in Texas

Appraisal settles disputes about the amount of a claim, not fault or coverage. You and the insurer each hire an appraiser, the two pick an umpire, and if the appraisers differ, the umpire decides; that decision binds you both. You pay your appraiser and half the umpire's costs. It applies only to disputes with your own insurer. [3] See How the Appraisal Clause Works.

How Long the Insurer Has

Under Texas's prompt payment rules for your own insurer, as the Department of Insurance describes them: [3]

  • Acknowledge your claim within 15 days of notice.
  • Accept or reject it within 15 business days of receiving everything it needs, or up to 45 days if it explains the delay. A denial must be explained in writing.
  • Send payment within five business days of agreeing to pay.

These deadlines do not apply to the other driver's insurer, but it must still act in good faith and settle fairly and promptly. [3]

The Deadline to Sue

Texas generally requires a lawsuit for injury to the property of another to be brought within two years. [6] Exceptions exist, so talk to a lawyer if you are close to that statute of limitations.

Where to Get Help in Texas

The Texas Department of Insurance answers questions at 800-252-3439. Complaints must be in writing, through its online complaint portal. [3]

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Texas allow diminished value claims?

Against the at-fault driver's insurer, the claim is measured under tort law, and that is the usual route. Under the standard Texas personal auto policy, the Texas Supreme Court held in 2003 that your own insurer does not owe diminished value for an adequately repaired car.

What percentage makes a car a total loss in Texas?

The Texas Department of Insurance gives no fixed percentage. It says a car is likely totaled when repairs cost about as much as the car is worth or more.

Who pays for an appraisal in Texas?

You pay your own appraiser and half of the umpire's costs. The insurer pays its appraiser and the other half.

How long do I have to sue for car damage in Texas?

Generally two years for injury to the property of another, under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 16.003, with exceptions.

How do I contact the Texas Department of Insurance?

Call 800-252-3439 with questions. Complaints must be submitted in writing through its online complaint portal.

About This Content

Published by Value Pilot
Last updated: November 10, 2026

Value Pilot publishes educational information to help vehicle owners understand vehicle valuation and insurance claim documentation. Content is based on publicly available regulatory, legal, and industry sources and is reviewed periodically for accuracy. Insurance requirements vary by state, policy, claim type, and circumstances. Value Pilot does not provide legal advice, and estimates or analyses do not guarantee a particular insurance settlement or claim outcome.

Sources & References

  1. [1] American Manufacturers Mutual Insurance Co. v. Schaefer, No. 02-0295 (Tex. Oct. 24, 2003)
  2. [2] Smither v. Progressive County Mutual Insurance Co., No. 14-01-00064-CV (Tex. App. Apr. 25, 2002)
  3. [3] Texas Department of Insurance — Auto Insurance Guide
  4. [4] Texas Department of Insurance — My Car Was Totaled! Now What?
  5. [5] Texas Department of Insurance — My Totaled Car Is Worth More Than Insurance Wants to Pay
  6. [6] Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 16.003 — Two-Year Limitations Period

Related reading