Skip to content
Featured guide

Progressive Colorado Total Loss Settlement: How to Claim

A proposed class action settlement covers some Colorado drivers whose totaled cars were paid by Progressive Direct or Progressive Preferred. Here is who is included, what the payment is, and how to file before the deadline, as of November 2026.

Value Pilot is independent. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Progressive, and we are not involved in this case or its settlement. This page reflects court documents as of November 2026 and is general information, not legal advice.

Who Is Included

The court notice describes two groups of people who made a first-party claim, meaning a claim on their own personal auto policy, where the policy was issued to a Colorado resident: [1]

  • Progressive Direct Insurance Company policyholders whose claim was submitted from April 12, 2019 through July 8, 2026.
  • Progressive Preferred Insurance Company policyholders whose claim was submitted from December 19, 2021 through July 8, 2026.

In both groups, Progressive must have decided the car was a total loss and based its payment on a Mitchell valuation report in which a "projected sold adjustment" was applied to at least one comparable vehicle. [1]

The settlement covers claims on your own Progressive policy. It does not describe claims you made against another driver's Progressive policy. [1]

What the Case Is About

When an insurer totals a car, it usually sets the actual cash value by looking at similar cars for sale, called comparable vehicles. The plaintiffs allege that the valuation reports lowered the prices of those comparable vehicles with a projected sold adjustment, that this was improper, and that it reduced what policyholders were paid. [1]

That is an allegation, not a finding. Progressive denies the allegations and agreed to settle without admitting liability. [2] In December 2023 the court let the case go forward as a class action, which is a ruling about procedure, not about who is right. [3]

How Much the Payment Is

Each valid claim is paid 68 percent of a set share of the car's actual cash value as recorded by Progressive: 2.75 percent for Progressive Direct claims and 2.25 percent for Progressive Preferred claims. [1]

Illustrative example

A $20,000 car under the settlement formula

Actual cash value in Progressive's records
$20,000
Progressive Direct: $20,000 × 2.75% × 68%
about $374
Progressive Preferred: $20,000 × 2.25% × 68%
about $306

Your own figure depends on the value in Progressive's records.

The notice says attorney fees, costs and service awards are paid separately by Progressive and do not reduce the money available to class members. [1]

How to File a Claim

  1. 1.Find the postcard or email notice you were sent. It carries a Claimant ID or total loss claim number and a PIN. [1]
  2. 2.File online at the settlement website named in the notice, COTotalLossClaim.com, or sign and mail the postcard claim form. [1]
  3. 3.If you did not get a notice and think you qualify, call the settlement administrator at 1-888-808-1463 and ask for a claim form. [1]
  4. 4.Submit or postmark it by February 5, 2027. Online claims close at 11:59 p.m. Eastern that day. [1]

The notice is direct on this point: the only way to get a payment is to submit a timely and valid claim form. If you do nothing, you get no payment and are still bound by the settlement's release. [1]

Dates to Know

  • November 5, 2026: the deadline to exclude yourself or object. It has passed. [1]
  • January 6, 2027, 10:00 a.m.: the fairness hearing in federal court in Denver. The court may change the date. [1]
  • February 5, 2027: the claim form deadline. [1]

Payment is not immediate. The notice says no settlement benefits will be provided unless the court approves the settlement, and the agreement ties payment to the settlement becoming final after any appeal period. [1] [2]

What You Give Up

Class members agree not to sue Progressive over the facts of this case, including claims arising out of how Progressive settled the total loss claim. The notice says the release does not cover claims for personal injury, medical payment, or uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage. [1] If you have a separate dispute with Progressive about the same total loss, ask a Colorado attorney how the release affects it before you assume anything.

Other Colorado Total Loss Rules Worth Knowing

These apply to any insurer, not just Progressive.

  • Colorado's Division of Insurance, quoting state law, says an insurer must pay title fees, sales tax, and any other transfer or registration fee associated with a total loss. Its December 2024 bulletin says this includes registration fees even when you keep the salvage, and that it applies to first and third party claims. The bulletin is guidance and is not itself binding. [4]
  • The Division says it does not decide what coverage is owed and cannot negotiate a settlement for you, but it can review how the company handled your claim if you file a complaint. [5]

Not in the Class, or Still Negotiating?

The settlement only covers past claims that fit the definitions above. If you are negotiating a total loss offer right now, with any insurer, read how insurers use comparable vehicles and how to dispute a total loss valuation, and look for any line in the report that lowers the comparable vehicles' prices.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to file a claim to get paid from the Progressive Colorado settlement?

Yes. The court notice says the only way to get a payment is to submit a timely and valid claim form, online or by mail, by February 5, 2027.

Has the settlement been approved?

Not finally. The fairness hearing is scheduled for January 6, 2027, and the court must still decide whether to approve it.

Did the court find that Progressive underpaid total loss claims?

No. Progressive denies the allegations and settled without admitting liability. The 2023 class certification order did not decide whether anyone was underpaid.

What is a projected sold adjustment?

In this case, it is the name for a reduction applied to the prices of comparable vehicles in the Mitchell valuation reports Progressive used. The plaintiffs allege it was improper; Progressive denies that.

Can I still opt out?

No. The notice set November 5, 2026 as the postmark deadline to exclude yourself or object, and that date has passed.

Does the settlement cover diminished value?

No. It concerns how totaled cars were valued. Separately, Colorado's Division of Insurance says there are no Colorado insurance laws that address diminished value.

About This Content

Published by Value Pilot
Last updated: November 13, 2026

Value Pilot publishes educational information to help vehicle owners understand vehicle valuation and insurance claim documentation. Content is based on publicly available regulatory, legal, and industry sources and is reviewed periodically for accuracy. Insurance requirements vary by state, policy, claim type, and circumstances. Value Pilot does not provide legal advice, and estimates or analyses do not guarantee a particular insurance settlement or claim outcome.

Sources & References

  1. [1] Court-approved class notice, Curran, et al. v. Progressive Direct Ins. Co., et al., No. 1:22-cv-00878 (D. Colo.) (copy on a third-party host; official site: COTotalLossClaim.com)
  2. [2] Class Action Settlement Agreement (June 29, 2026), Curran v. Progressive Direct Insurance Co., No. 1:22-cv-00878 (D. Colo.), ECF No. 216-1 (copy on a third-party host)
  3. [3] Curran v. Progressive Direct Insurance Co., No. 22-cv-00878 (D. Colo. Dec. 18, 2023) (order on class certification)
  4. [4] Colorado Division of Insurance — Bulletin No. B-5.51, Concerning Insurer's Payment of Registration Fees for Total Loss Vehicles (December 10, 2024)
  5. [5] Colorado Division of Insurance — Auto Insurance

Related reading

Check your offer against the market.

Free · About 60 seconds · No email needed