Skip to content
Featured guide

Missouri Total Loss Valuation: What Insurers Were Told

Missouri's insurance regulator has put insurers on notice about how valuation software prices totaled cars. Here is what it said, what it does and does not change, and how to use it on your own claim, as of November 2026. This is general information, not legal advice.

What Missouri Told Insurers

The Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance published Bulletin 26-04, "Claims Valuation Software," dated March 17, 2026. [1] It is aimed at insurers that use software to set the actual cash value of a totaled vehicle.

The bulletin says insurers relying on this software should be aware it can undervalue total loss vehicles, potentially in violation of Missouri's Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act. It names two causes: condition adjustments that are arbitrary or undocumented, and details about the specific vehicle that the software does not capture. [2]

It also explains how the software works. The software sets a base value by comparing your car with similar vehicles. The insurer can choose a starting point that lowers those comparable vehicles from dealer "ready to sell" condition toward the condition of a privately owned car, and that starting point can already include a deduction for wear. The claims handler can then adjust further for options, condition and mileage. [2]

That matters because the same wear can be counted twice: once inside the software and once by the person handling your claim.

Five Things the Bulletin Asks Insurers to Consider

The bulletin encourages insurers to consider five points when they value a totaled car: [2]

  • Identify and apply the options specific to your vehicle, including dealer trim packages.
  • Consider upgrades made after purchase that may be covered under the policy.
  • Make sure condition deductions made by the claims handler do not duplicate deductions the software already applied.
  • Increase the value when your car was in better condition than the software's condition ratings assume.
  • Avoid adjusting values based on negotiation tactics such as haggling, which the bulletin calls highly subjective.

What Has to Be in Your Claim File

This part rests on a regulation, not just the bulletin. Missouri's claims settlement rule says that when the amount claimed is reduced because of betterment or depreciation, all information for the reduction must be in the claim file, and the reductions must be itemized and appropriate in amount. [3]

The bulletin applies that rule to valuation software. It says adjustments based on betterment or depreciation must be documented in the claim file, itemized, explained, and fair and reasonable. It instructs insurers to state what was deducted, how your vehicle differs from the comparable vehicles, and why. It adds that the software inputs, such as weighting and condition settings, need to be kept in the file too. [2]

What the Bulletin Does Not Do

It is worth being clear about the limits, so you do not overstate your position with the adjuster.

  • A bulletin is guidance. Missouri law says department bulletins do not have the force or effect of law and are not binding on the department or an insurer. [4] The regulation it cites is binding; the five points above are things insurers are encouraged to consider.
  • It does not set the value of your car or say any particular offer is too low.
  • The Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act is enforced by the department. The Act says it does not create a private cause of action, meaning you cannot sue an insurer simply for violating it. [5] Other legal claims may exist; that is a question for a Missouri attorney.
  • The department says it cannot establish the value of a claim or the amount owed to you in a dispute with your insurer. [6]

How to Use This on Your Own Claim

  1. 1.Ask for the full valuation report, not just the offer amount. Our guide to reading a CCC valuation report explains the sections you will see.
  2. 2.Find every condition adjustment and every deduction applied to the comparable vehicles. Ask the adjuster, in writing, what was deducted, how your car differs from each comparable, and why.
  3. 3.Ask whether the starting value already includes a deduction for wear, and whether any condition deduction was applied on top of it.
  4. 4.List your car's options, trim package and any upgrades, with receipts, and ask that each one be reflected in the value.
  5. 5.If your car was in better shape than the report's condition ratings suggest, send photos and service records and ask for an upward adjustment.
  6. 6.Gather your own comparable vehicles for sale near you. See how insurers use comparable vehicles and how to dispute a total loss valuation.

Keep the tone factual. You are asking the insurer to show its work, which Missouri's rule already requires it to keep on file. [3]

Where to Get Help in Missouri

The Department of Commerce and Insurance takes complaints online, by mail or by fax, and runs an Insurance Consumer Hotline at 800-726-7390 on weekdays from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. It can forward your complaint to the company and review the company's response for compliance with Missouri law. It cannot decide what your claim is worth. [6]

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Missouri Bulletin 26-04?

It is a March 17, 2026 bulletin from the Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance titled "Claims Valuation Software." It warns insurers that valuation software can undervalue totaled vehicles and reminds them to document every condition deduction.

Is the Missouri bulletin legally binding on my insurer?

No. Missouri law says department bulletins do not have the force or effect of law and are not binding. The claims settlement rule the bulletin cites is a regulation, and it does require betterment and depreciation reductions to be itemized in the claim file.

Can a Missouri insurer deduct for my car's condition?

Yes, but the reduction has to be documented. Missouri's rule requires all information for a betterment or depreciation reduction to be in the claim file, itemized and appropriate in amount. The bulletin adds that a deduction should not duplicate one the software already applied.

Can the Missouri insurance department make my insurer pay more?

No. The department says it cannot establish the value of a claim or the amount owed to you. It can forward your complaint and review the insurer's response for compliance with Missouri law.

Does the bulletin apply if the other driver's insurer is paying?

The bulletin does not say it is limited to claims under your own policy; it addresses insurers that use valuation software on total loss vehicles. If you are unsure how it applies to your claim, ask the department or a Missouri attorney.

About This Content

Published by Value Pilot
Last updated: November 11, 2026

Value Pilot publishes educational information to help vehicle owners understand vehicle valuation and insurance claim documentation. Content is based on publicly available regulatory, legal, and industry sources and is reviewed periodically for accuracy. Insurance requirements vary by state, policy, claim type, and circumstances. Value Pilot does not provide legal advice, and estimates or analyses do not guarantee a particular insurance settlement or claim outcome.

Sources & References

  1. [1] Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance — Bulletins (entry 26-04, Claims Valuation Software, March 17, 2026)
  2. [2] Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance — Bulletin 26-04, Claims Valuation Software
  3. [3] Missouri Code of State Regulations, 20 CSR 100-1.050 — Unfair Claims Settlement Practices
  4. [4] Missouri Revised Statutes § 374.015 — Bulletins
  5. [5] Missouri Revised Statutes § 375.1000 — Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act
  6. [6] Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance — Insurance Complaints

Related reading

Check your offer against the market.

Free · About 60 seconds · No email needed